If you’re a parent whose child is struggling to read, you might wonder why their teacher seems uncertain about phonics instruction. It’s a fair question, and the answer might surprise you: many teachers were never taught how to teach phonics in their college education programs.

This isn’t about blaming teachers. In fact, most teachers are just as frustrated by this gap in their training as parents are. When educators learn about the research supporting systematic phonics instruction, they often ask, “Why didn’t anyone teach me this in college?”

The Legacy of Reading Wars

For decades, American education has been caught in what’s often called “the reading wars“—a long-standing debate about the best way to teach children to read. On one side stood phonics, focused on teaching children to decode words by learning letter-sound relationships. On the other side was the whole-language approach, which emphasized reading for meaning from the start and assumed that children would pick up phonics naturally through exposure to books.

Throughout much of the late 20th century, whole language dominated teacher education programs. Many teachers who graduated between the 1970s and early 2000s were taught that explicit phonics instruction was unnecessary or even harmful. They learned instead to teach children to memorize whole words, use picture clues, and guess from context, strategies now known as the “three-cueing system.”

These teachers weren’t given inadequate training because their professors were careless or uninformed. At the time, whole language was considered best practice by many literacy experts. Teacher education programs were simply teaching what the field believed to be true.

What Changed

While whole language instruction dominated classrooms, researchers in cognitive science, neuroscience, and psychology were making discoveries about how the brain actually learns to read. Study after study confirmed that explicit, systematic phonics instruction helps children learn to read more effectively than other approaches.

In 2000, the National Reading Panel examined decades of research and confirmed that phonics instruction is essential for teaching children to read. They identified five key components of effective reading instruction: phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension.

But here’s a challenge: research findings published in academic journals don’t automatically change what happens in college classrooms or elementary schools. Even as evidence mounted in favor of phonics instruction, many teacher education programs continued teaching the methods they’d always taught.

The Reality of Teacher Preparation

Consider what teacher preparation programs must cover. Elementary education majors need to learn how to teach reading, writing, math, science, social studies, and more, all within a four-year degree program. At one university, reading and literacy courses account for just 15 of the 124 hours required for graduation.

Within those limited hours, professors must cover an enormous amount of ground. Even when programs include phonics instruction, students might not receive enough depth or practice to feel confident teaching it. A student might complete their education courses, do their student teaching in a fourth-grade classroom where reading instruction looks different from that in kindergarten, and then get hired to teach first grade, where children are just learning to read.

It’s no wonder many new teachers feel unprepared.

The Challenge Intensifies

The teacher shortage has made this situation more complicated. Many states now issue large numbers of emergency teaching certificates to fill vacant positions. These individuals often have no formal teacher training upon entering the classroom. While emergency certification helps schools stay staffed, it means more children are being taught by adults who haven’t received any preparation in reading instruction.

Some states now require emergency-certified teachers to complete professional development training in reading science. That’s a positive step, but it doesn’t help the thousands of veteran teachers who completed their education before the importance of phonics was widely recognized in teacher training.

Move Forward Without Blame

Understanding why teachers weren’t taught phonics helps us respond constructively rather than with criticism. Teachers are doing their best with the training they received. Many are actively seeking better information about how to help their struggling readers.

When teachers learn about the research supporting phonics instruction, most respond with relief rather than defensiveness. They’ve often seen students struggle with the methods they were taught. Learning about systematic phonics gives them new tools that actually work.

Some states are taking steps to address these gaps. They’re updating teacher education requirements, providing professional development focused on reading science, and supporting teachers as they learn new approaches. These changes take time, but they’re happening.

What Parents Can Do

If your child’s teacher seems unsure about phonics instruction, remember this probably reflects their training rather than their dedication or care for students. Many teachers are working hard to fill in the gaps in their own education while simultaneously teaching full classrooms of children.

You can support both your child and their teacher by asking questions respectfully, sharing information about reading research when appropriate, and advocating at the district level for professional development in systematic phonics instruction.

Teachers didn’t choose to be inadequately prepared for teaching reading. They deserve support as they work to learn what they weren’t taught in college. With better training and resources, they can become the effective reading teachers every child deserves.

For more information about evidence-based reading instruction and resources for both parents and teachers, visit Phonics.org regularly. Together, we can ensure every child learns to read.