Your third grader still struggles to decode simple words. Your English language learner confuses similar sounds. Your high schooler avoids reading aloud at all costs. These scenarios play out in classrooms and homeschools daily, leaving educators wondering: Does phonics instruction work for everyone?

The answer is yes, but the delivery might need adjustment. Research consistently shows that systematic, explicit phonics instruction benefits all learners, including those with dyslexia, English language learners, and older students who missed foundational skills. The key lies not in abandoning proven methods but in thoughtfully adapting them to meet specific needs.

Understanding the Core Principle: Keep It Systematic

Before exploring adaptations, one principle must remain clear: systematic phonics instruction should stay systematic for virtually all learners. This means teaching letter-sound relationships in a logical, defined sequence, moving from simple to complex concepts in a way that builds on previous learning.

Systematic phonics instruction produces significant benefits for students in kindergarten through sixth grade, particularly for those who struggle with reading. This systematic approach provides the predictable structure that many students with learning differences need to succeed.

The temptation to abandon sequence and jump around based on perceived student interests, or to rely solely on sight-word memorization, can actually harm long-term progress. Even students who learn differently benefit most from knowing there’s a clear roadmap forward, where each new skill connects logically to what came before.

Adapt Without Abandoning: Key Modifications

While maintaining systematic instruction, several adaptations can make phonics more accessible for specialized populations. The most important adjustment often involves pacing. In typical classrooms, phonics programs introduce three to five new letter-sound relationships weekly. For some learners, this pace is overwhelming. Slowing to one or two new concepts per week, with daily practice and review, allows knowledge to solidify before adding new information.

Multisensory instruction becomes crucial for many learners with differences. This means engaging sight, sound, touch, and movement simultaneously during lessons. Students might trace letters in sand while saying sounds aloud, use magnetic letters to physically manipulate word parts, or incorporate body movements that correspond to specific phonemes. These approaches create multiple neural pathways for storing and retrieving information, particularly beneficial for students with dyslexia.

For English language learners, educators must consider which sounds are present in students’ home languages and which require new learning. Some phonemes have no equivalent in certain languages, requiring explicit attention and extra practice. Teachers should also ensure students understand the instruction itself. Students can’t learn phonics if they don’t understand the teacher’s directions. Using visual supports, demonstrations, and checking for understanding becomes essential.

Pre-teaching and overlearning represent powerful strategies for many specialized populations. Pre-teaching introduces concepts before whole-group lessons, giving students a preview that builds confidence. Overlearning means practicing skills beyond initial mastery until they become automatic. Short, focused sessions revisiting previously taught concepts help cement learning in long-term memory.

Meet Older Students Where They Are

Teaching phonics to older students requires particular sensitivity. Middle and high school students who lack foundational decoding skills often feel embarrassed about their reading struggles. The key lies in presenting phonics as the sophisticated adult skill it truly is; the ability to tackle complex vocabulary in any field requires strong phonics knowledge.

Research from McKinsey & Company shows that many secondary students fell significantly behind in reading during recent disruptions to education, with some high schoolers reading at elementary levels. These students need systematic phonics instruction, but with age-appropriate materials and context. Using technical vocabulary from subjects they care about, connecting phonics to career interests, or framing lessons around decoding sophisticated words helps maintain engagement.

Word study at the secondary level often expands beyond basic phonics to include morphology, prefixes, suffixes, and root words. This bridges phonics knowledge with the academic vocabulary students encounter across content areas. When students understand that “bio” means life and appears in biology, biography, and biosphere, they gain both decoding strategy and content knowledge.

When to Add Supplementary Approaches

For a small percentage of students, particularly those with severe dyslexia or other specific learning differences, systematic phonics instruction alone may need to be supplemented with additional strategies. Teaching onset and rime patterns, syllable division rules, and using targeted mnemonics for irregular high-frequency words can provide extra tools without replacing systematic phonics as the foundation.

However, these additions should enhance rather than replace explicit phonics instruction. The goal remains building a reliable decoding system that works for any word, supplemented by strategies for particularly tricky patterns or words.

Build Confidence Through Success

Across all specialized populations, confidence matters enormously. Students who’ve struggled with reading often develop anxiety and avoidance behaviors around literacy activities. Using fully decodable texts, books containing only letter-sound relationships that students have already learned, ensures every reading session is successful. This builds the confidence needed to persist through challenging learning.

Regular assessment helps ensure instruction matches student needs. When progress stalls, thoughtful analysis can reveal whether pacing needs adjustment, whether additional multisensory elements would help, or whether outside factors require attention. Flexibility within the systematic framework allows responsive teaching without abandoning structure.

Your Path Forward With Specialized Learners

Teaching phonics to specialized populations doesn’t require abandoning research-based practices. It requires thoughtful adaptation of proven methods to honor both the science of reading and individual learning profiles. Systematic instruction provides the framework; multisensory techniques, appropriate pacing, and targeted support fill in the details.

For more research-backed strategies on adapting phonics instruction for diverse learners and building strong foundations for all readers, explore the expert resources at Phonics.org. Every child deserves access to the literacy skills that unlock learning across every subject.